hotel for couple

9 Best 5 star hotels in Sayre, PA (2022)

5 star hotels in Sayre, PA

1. The Brimarie (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 119 S Elmer Ave, Sayre, PA 18840
  • Phone: (570) 888-8800
  • Ratings: 4.5 (162 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : The Brimarie
  • Check-in time: 2:00 PM
  • Quick Summary: Elegant rooms & suites, a restaurant, & free WiFi & continental breakfast at this Victorian option.

About this hotel

A historic Victorian inn is 1 block from Elmer Park, 6 blocks from the Susquehanna River and 7.8 miles from Tioga Downs Casino.The traditional, elegant 8 guest rooms & suites – some with whirlpool tubs, French doors, bay windows and private porches – have en suite marble bathrooms (shower and shower/bath combinations), some antique furnishings and free WiFi.Amenities include a lounge, a fine-dining restaurant, free daily continental breakfast, free parking (limited) and a small patio with seating. Limited event space is available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Walking distance to Sayre Historical Society and Riverfront Park
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned “steak” 13 times
  • Guests mentioned “pizzas” 10 times
  • Guests liked the breakfast
  • Guests praised the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

bob V

I stopped in for a quick lunch last weekI ordered a Caesar salad with steakHonestly, it was the best Caesar I have ever had

The Salad was so big I could not eat all of it but I didpick out all the very tasty steak that was on topI will stop here again soonThe place is so nice and cozyThis place is well maintained and clean I wishit was in my home townNext time I visit I will try some of their othermenu itemsGreat Place !!!!!!

Margo Love

Luncheon two timesScrumptious food!Delightful waitressLorraine, owner, made wonderful accomodations for my husband who is handicapped

Very gracious hospitalityWhite fabric tablecloths added to the ambience Highly recommended! *****

Susan Birkhead

I really di like it much, I was there a few years ago and it was very good for lunch and dinner Last week 3of my friends went to lunch, sat outside

the waitress was very nice but as far as our lunch my opinionit wasn’t worth it I had the lobster sandwich which didn’t have lobster in itit was the fake seafood, there wasn’t much on your sandwich and it was plopped on potato breadwas not worth $1400 it came with fries and they were better than the sandwich, 2 of my friends had the chicken salad sandwich again, not much on taste, not much on the potato breadthey weren’t happy either My other friend had the steak salad, it looked pretty good but she didn’t say anything about it good or bad We won’t be coming back there anytim soon We could have went elsewhere and had a better lunch and not as expensive The waitress told us when we mentioned we weren’t happy with our lunch that they got a different cook Well he stinks Dandy has better sandwiches

2. Fainting Goat Island Inn

About this hotel

1311 W River Rd, Nichols, NY 13812(607) 972-9849

Things You Need to Know

  • 3 min drive to Tioga Downs
  • Guests praised the service

Feedback From Real Customers

Diane Henssler

The instant I stepped inside this amazing inn I felt warmly welcomed! My friendly, wonderful hosts gave me a tour of the inn and beautiful grounds Every aspect of this clean, wonderfully decorated and comfortable Inn made my stay so fantasticOf course I enjoyed the cinnamon buns and coffee! However, sitting on the balcony, bird watching and observing river water life made it a marvelous memory!I also enjoyed meeting other guests and chatting with the hosts Truly, it was the surprisingly the greatest Inn or B&B that I have ever experienced!It is what you make it , but all of the ingredients are here for a terrific stay!

Anthony Polimino

All accommodations were clean and immaculate The grounds were very beautiful and even though there was a drought, we still had colorful gardens All the antiques were beautiful Victorian era pieces

As soon as we arrived, Marnie made us feel right at home welcoming us with open arms Larry, the house cat, was very friendly On our second night we did a ghost hunt with Bill and Marnie and the rest of the guests… very excitingThank you again, Bill and Marnie, for a wonderful relaxing stay We look forward to returning for a visit in the fallPatricia and AnthonyMilford, PA

Danielle Beebe

This was our third time at the Inn and we plan to be back again Marnie and Bill are more than accommodating and make you feel right at home The place is beautiful, clean and has activities close by

The goats are always fun to feed and very entertaining Marnie makes the best cinnamon rolls for breakfast as well We recommend the room with the private balcony Definitely a fun spot and we can’t wait to go back!Ryan & Danielle

3. Comfort Inn & Suites (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 2160 Elmira St, Sayre, PA 18840
  • Phone: (570) 888-1100
  • Ratings: 4.5 (403 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : Comfort Inn & Suites
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Modern hotel with straightforward rooms featuring free Wi-Fi, plus BBQ grills on a patio & a pool.

About this hotel

A block from Route 220, this modern hotel is 1.8 miles from the Sayre Historical Society Museum and 2.4 miles from Tioga Point Museum.Modern rooms feature free Wi-Fi and have en suite bathrooms with showers, as well as flat-screen TVs, coffeemakers, minifridges and microwaves. Suites add kitchenettes, pull-out sofas and whirlpool tubs.Freebies include hot breakfast, 24-hour coffee, and outdoor parking. There’s an indoor heated pool, and a patio with BBQ grills and shaded picnic tables. Other amenities include computer access in the business center, an exercise room and meeting space.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms
  • 5 min drive to Sayre Historical Society
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests liked the beds, mentioned 22 times in reviews
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an outdoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Jenny Wright

I love this place The staff are always super friendly, and helpful They welcome pets

☺️ They recently had the pool renovated and it’s amazing The breakfast is hot and amazing They serve foods such as bacon, eggs, pancakes, and so on The rooms are clean and cozy The outside area for pets is a little limited, but more than enough for any four legged family member to handle business I will stay again, and again Please utilize this facility and allow for this chain to offer their services instead of the surrounding chains that aren’t pet friendly

David Stedge

They have the GREATEST, Professional workers I have ever dealt with in any of the Hotels that I have stayed at across the Country They know what being “Courtesy” means They have a good spread for Breakfast food, Comfortable beds, Great Housekeepers, Great Front desk workers, Awesome Managers

They treat you like Family On a scale of 1-10, I would have to give them a 15 They have Good, Clean rooms They CARE about their Guests

Michele Panella

I stayed at this hotel on 2/22/22-2/23/22 I am a travel nurse I worked a 16 hour shift from 3pm-7am and had to be back to work at 7pm

I booked a room so I could sleep for a few hours before working my next shift I called to see if I could check-in earlier than 3pm The front desk employee said that I could That was great The check-in process was simple and quick My room was clean and spacious Here is the reason I only gave the hotel 3 stars: As soon as I got into my room, I heard dogs barking The room next to mine had a couple dogs and they barked and barked and barked I love animals but try falling asleep with dogs barking continuously I didn’t complain to the front desk because I didn’t want the dogs and their owners to have to leave When I checked in, I did tell the front desk that I was there to sleep I don’t think they should have put me in a room next to barking dogs And I know that the front desk could hear them because the rooms were right past the swimming pool

4. Hampton Inn Sayre (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 3080 N Elmira St, Sayre, PA 18840
  • Phone: (570) 882-1166
  • Ratings: 4.6 (384 reviews) Excellent Eco-certified
  • Website : Hampton Inn Sayre
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Casual hotel with free hot breakfast & Wi-Fi, plus an indoor pool, a fitness center & meeting space.

About this hotel

This modern hotel is a 13-minute walk from the Chemung River and 0.4 miles from Spanish Hill.Relaxed rooms include free Wi-Fi, custom-designed beds, and both full and lap desks (for working on the bed). They also have flat-screen TVs with HD channels, and coffeemakers. Some have microwaves and minifridges; suites provide additional space and pull-out sofas.Free perks include hot breakfast (daily) and weekday breakfast bags to go. There’s also a fitness center and an indoor pool, plus a business center and a meeting room.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms, which have minibars
  • The rooms have TVs
  • 4 min drive to Susquehanna River Archaeological Center SRAC
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests liked the pool, mentioned 20 times in reviews

Feedback From Real Customers

Lynda Rice

Very impressed with this hotel A step above most Attentive staff, lots of perks (bottled water, GOOD coffee, candy, cookies, breakfast)

The room was nicely laid out, spacious and clean Comfortable bed and pillows A fridge and a microwave, as well as a small sink outside the bathroom Definitely recommend if you are in that area, even if you have to go a little out of your way! Excellent!

M B

A very nice hotel with super friendly staff I also appreciate the possibility of using the gym and the pool There is a small tear us to sit outside which is also nice

The hotel is just beside at Tops supermarket so very convenient if you need to grab some groceries in the late evening Service in the hotel and breakfast is great A clear recommendation

Anir

This hotel calls for refresh very badly! Lobby & Breakfast area fantastic That’s it – then it all 1980’s once you take the elevatorThe carpets are stained not ONLY in the room but all across – lobby, etc

It doesn’t mean it’s dirty but it calls for a replacementMy bathroom was clogged very badly So bad that maintenance needs to be called & got fixed only on the next day out of 2 days stay!It’s clean but worn out hotelThey ran out of white bread, can you imagine I think they bought 2 lbs of bread for ALL guestsWhen I had asked for 2 extra towels, the Front Desk lady ask my Room Number Looks like the management counts every cents they spent on GuestsThis is Hilton with Motel attitude

5. O’Briens Inn (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 33 County Rd 60, Waverly, NY 14892
  • Phone: (607) 565-2817
  • Ratings: 4.2 (281 reviews) Very good
  • Website : O’Briens Inn
  • Check-in time: 1:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: It’s all about the view at this hilltop hotel with modern comforts in the rooms and a public bar.

About this hotel

This hilltop inn famed for its views is 2.3 miles from Waverly and 1.3 miles from the I-86 highway, with New York 3 hrs 30 mins away. All rooms have free WiFi, TVs with cable channels, air-conditioning, desks, fridges, microwaves plus tea and coffeemaking facilities. All rooms have views and some include panoramic balconies.The bar and lounge is open for drinks and snacks and guests can eat on their private balconies. Free parking is available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms
  • 2 min drive to Waverly Glen Park
  • Guests liked the service
  • Guests mentioned restaurant menus 13 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • Guests praised the views

Feedback From Real Customers

Deanna Barrett

My family was visiting from New Jersey for my sons graduation party they had 5 rooms booked at O’Briens There was a water break situation at the motel and they weren’t able to accommodate all 5 rooms Jesse, one of the owners suggested they all stay together at a local chain hotel, he made the call and over accommodated my family

Don’t overlook O‘Briens for your out of town guests or while visiting the finger lake regionRenovated rooms, bar and lounge Good food and a beautiful viewThank you for taking great care of my family and our plans

Lorie Anderson

Attended a wedding & reception here The window shade was broken and wouldn’t go down to accommodate photos without the glare off the windows Food service wasn’t up to par

chicken was dry, garlic knots didn’t come out with the rest of the meal, as previously arranged, had to ask for water and rice was provided that was not on the menu; the wedding toast was not what was arranged for as requested There was no one go-to events manager for assistance and Management didn’t seem to place a priority on the event No prior preparations were made as far as table setup, linens, etc I would not hold an event here

Marcus Coppola

The food is fantastic It truly ranks with the best in the area From

wings to steaks you can’t do better for your money period The food you see made by Chris Streeter and 6 beverages was just under a hundred Ann came to the table and packed our leftovers Excellent draft beers including local crafts At home like service and the best wings money can buy Oh, the scenery is good too

6. Crystal Springs Inn and Suites (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 20485 US-220, Towanda, PA 18848
  • Phone: (570) 265-2726
  • Ratings: 4.4 (158 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Crystal Springs Inn and Suites
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: A gym, plus free parking, WiFi & daily waffles & coffee at this standard option with rooms & suites.

About this hotel

This straightforward hotel is 6.9 miles from Hornbrook Park on the Susquehanna River, 13.5 miles from Mt. Pisgah State Park and 26 miles from Tioga Downs Casino.The 34 suites in a newer facility feature free WiFi, fridges, microwaves, private balconies or patios, kitchenettes and living rooms. Many have mountain views. Ten rooms are available in a separate 1-story older facility. Amenities include free daily breakfast waffles and coffee, guest laundry facilities, a small cafe and food market, a gym, as well as free car, RV and truck parking.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms and the kitchenettes
  • 8 min drive to Endless Mountains Heritage Region, Inc.
  • Guests mentioned the service is friendly

Feedback From Real Customers

MSC

My husband and his co-workers have been staying there for years when they are in town for work Sometimes I come to visit with our children too There is plenty of space and places to sleep because the rooms are basically an apartment

It’s also nice to have a kitchen area to cook and make meals The balcony is an added bonus The staff are always extremely helpful and friendly They take great care of their guests and understand that a lot of them are working away from their families for extended periods of time A special thank you to Hannah, for always taking care of us!

7. Best Western Grand Victorian Inn (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

In a wooded residential area off I-86, this modest hotel is 2 miles from Shepard Hills Country Club and 11 miles from Tioga Downs Casino & Racing.Relaxed rooms come with complimentary Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and tea and coffeemakers, as well as microwaves and minifridges. Some rooms have whirlpool tubs and wet bars. Kids 17 and under stay at no cost with an adult.Cooked breakfast and parking are free. There’s also a relaxed bar/restaurant, and a garden with a gazebo. Other amenities include an exercise room, an indoor pool and a sauna, as well as a racquetball court and a business center.

Things You Need to Know

  • The rooms have coffee makers
  • Guests praised the bathrooms
  • 4 min drive to Sayre Historical Society
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “waffles” 12 times
  • Guests praised the fitness center, which has weight machines
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub

Feedback From Real Customers

Theresa McCauslin

My husband had surgery at Guthrie Robert Packet Hospital and this was right off 17 & close to the hospital so very convenient Very friendly & accommodating front desk clerks We had a balcony room with a king bed & it was very clean

The bed was very comfortable & my husband is in a wheelchair & they made sure he was accommodated with the room & shower Very quiet and nice place!

Tyler Spence

Just had a recent stay in February I have stayed here every august since 2018 and each time I grow more and more impressed My most recent stay was in February

The staff is always very friendly The pool was an awesome temperature hot tub was awesome They have a lot of activities racquet ball fitness center etc breakfast was decent although I wish they had bagels and/or muffins Definitely will stay again

Romeo Cochrane

This resort was clean However, the air conditioning in the room was not working properly The room was pretty stuffy

Overall the facility seems a little worn and dated It ineeds to be spruced up and updated On the plus side the breakfast was good We particularly liked the waffles and fresh fruit A number of different choices spaciously laid out

8. Microtel Inn & Suites by Wyndham Sayre (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Off US-220, this low-key budget hotel is 2 miles from both Tioga Point Museum and Riverfront Park along the Susquehanna River.Casual rooms feature free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and desks, as well as microwaves, minifridges and coffeemakers. Family rooms sleep up to 4 guests. Suites add kitchenettes, and sitting areas with sofabeds.Continental breakfast is complimentary, as is parking. There are also guest laundry facilities.

Things You Need to Know

  • 5 min drive to Tioga Point Museum
  • Guests mentioned beds 24 times

Feedback From Real Customers

s dunn

Our stay has been wonderful! I will admit I was worried when I first saw the building I wasn’t sure what the rooms would be like, especially since we only paid about $88 a night! The rooms are really cute and clean We had a suite with a microwave, little fridge and a coffee maker

They’re very quaint and lovely! I will totally stay here again and would definitely recommend!

9. Sunrise Motel (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 3778 Waverly Rd, Owego, NY 13827
  • Phone: (607) 687-5666
  • Ratings: 2.9 (72 reviews) Fair
  • Website : Sunrise Motel
  • Check-in time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Modest rooms with no-nonsense decor, at this motel featuring free WiFi, breakfast & parking.

About this hotel

In a rural locale, this no-frills motel is a 4-minute drive from the laid-back town of Owego. On the scenic Susquehanna river, Owego offers relaxed shops and cafes. The fast cars at Shangri-la II motor speedway are a 7-minute drive.Basic rooms with functional decor offer free WiFi, air-conditioning, TVs with cable channels, as well as private bathrooms. Guests have access to a shared kitchenette.An included continental breakfast is available, while free off-street parking is provided.

Things You Need to Know

  • 4 min drive to Tioga County Historical Society
  • Guests liked the service
  • Some guests disliked the bathrooms

Feedback From Real Customers

LINDA FISHER

The room was disgustingly dirty as was the bathroom We had no washclothsAir conditioner needs a good cleaning, vents are covered in dust

The cost of the room was very reasonable, about half of what your big named motels areThe saving grace is that the clerk was very friendlyMost likely won’t be staying there again

Linda Short

It worked in a pinch Most of the staff was nice and friendly The man that I assume does maintenance was outside late at night arguing with his girlfriend which is not professional at all

The room itself is not worth the amount they charge Out dated! The bathroom was the worst the sink drained slow and idk what was coming up The toilet half the time didn’t flush The shower was the worst my 5 year old refused to shower there it was dark and dirty It worked for what we needed it for though

Kaitlyn Johnson (Kait/Kat)

I was here for a couple weeks Absolutely horrendous! Horrible owner does not wash bedding or towels i got dirty linen constantly and they would not allow to get new sheets or pillows or comforter so I had to purchase my own Also cockroach infestations almost every other month

They had multiple rooms closed due to exterminators being there

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.